- Sticking to the Script: Jonathan Bennett believes his iconic character, Aaron Samuels, should remain straight in a potential Mean Girls sequel to preserve the original story’s narrative.
- The Cast is Ready: Bennett confirmed that “99 percent” of the original cast is eager to return for another film, fueling long-standing fan hopes.
- A New Generation: He pitched his own sequel idea, envisioning the original characters as parents dealing with their own “mean girl” daughters in high school.
- A Contrasting View: While Bennett wants Aaron to stay straight, Mean Girls musical and remake star Reneé Rapp has famously stated she believes her character, Regina George, is “absolutely gay.”
Bennett’s Stance: Keep Aaron Samuels Straight
Jonathan Bennett, known for his role as the charming Aaron Samuels in the 2004 classic Mean Girls, has made his opinion clear on his character’s future: he should remain straight. Speaking on the I’ve Never Said This Before podcast with Tommy DiDario, Bennett addressed fan theories and hopes that Aaron might be portrayed as gay in a future sequel, reflecting Bennett’s own identity.
“I think Aaron would be straight,” Bennett stated firmly. “Because you wouldn’t go and change the narrative of Aaron Samuels because [Jonathan Bennett] is gay. You keep the narrative of Aaron Samuels because that’s the story.”
A Sequel Is Closer Than You Think
Despite his creative stance on the character, Bennett delivered exciting news for fans who have been waiting decades for a true sequel. He revealed that the desire for a reunion is strong among the original stars.
“I know that everyone wants to,” Bennett said about the sequel’s status. “I know that 99 percent of the cast is like, ‘Let’s go!'” This confirmation adds significant weight to the possibility that North Shore High could soon be back in session.
Mean Moms and a New Class of Plastics
Bennett didn’t just comment on the possibility of a sequel; he came with his own detailed pitch. He envisions a story that bridges the original millennial fanbase with a new teenage audience.
“The girls are grown up, you know, have their own kids, and now their daughters are coming to the school, and it’s managing the parents with the kids in high school,” he explained. In his version, the original cast would navigate the drama of being parents to a new generation of Plastics. He even had a message for the film’s writer, Tina Fey: “I mean, Tina, write it. I ain’t getting any younger, sweetie.”
The Film’s Unexpected LGBTQ+ Legacy
Bennett also reflected on the surprising number of gay actors who were part of the original male cast, including himself, Daniel Franzese (Damien), and Rajiv Surendra (Kevin G).
“Almost all the guys from Mean Girls are gay,” he joked. “And Mean Girls is one of the gayest cult classic movies of all time. So let’s think about that. What came first, the gay or the Mean Girls?”
A Different Perspective on Character Identity
While Bennett feels strongly about preserving Aaron’s original storyline, other actors have reinterpreted their characters through a modern lens. Lesbian actress Reneé Rapp, who has played Regina George on Broadway and in the 2024 musical movie, has publicly stated her belief that the ultimate queen bee is “absolutely, absolutely gay. That woman is a lesbian.” This highlights a fascinating divide in how actors approach the legacy of their iconic roles.
Image Referance: https://www.out.com/film/jonathan-bennett-mean-girls-sequel